Director
Charles Chaplin
Cast
Charlie Chaplin - The Tramp
Virginia Cherrill - the blind girl
Florence Lee - her grandmother
Harry Myers - the eccentric millionaire
Allan Garcia - his butler
Hank Mann - the prizefighter
Charlie Chaplin - The Tramp
Virginia Cherrill - the blind girl
Florence Lee - her grandmother
Harry Myers - the eccentric millionaire
Allan Garcia - his butler
Hank Mann - the prizefighter
These two movies demonstrate perfectly well how meticulous Chaplin is when telling a story. No detail goes unnoticed as he ensures all elements fall into place with the right pacing, and at the right time.
As I mentioned in my review of "The Kid," because of his artistic creativity and careful dedication, movies like "City Lights" hit all the right emotional chords with an almost flawless balance of comedy and drama.
In "City Lights," Charlie Chaplin falls in love with a flower girl (Virginia Cherrill) he happens to stumble into while out and about in the city.Of course, he buys a flower from her, and then figures out she's blind.
In "City Lights," Charlie Chaplin falls in love with a flower girl (Virginia Cherrill) he happens to stumble into while out and about in the city.Of course, he buys a flower from her, and then figures out she's blind.
Through a simple yet creative way only Chaplin could have thought up, she mistakes him for a wealthy man though she can't see. Determined to help improve her circumstances despite his own lack of resources, he navigates through various comedic misadventures, unlikely friendships, and personal sacrifices to help her obtain a better life, and her eyesight.
Between "City Lights," "The Kid" and his other amazing movie, "The Gold Rush" from 1925, I can't honestly point to any of these and say that's Charlie Chaplin's greatest movie. It's one hell of a toss-up. But I do lean heavily towards "City Lights" as being his greatest film achievement.
I guess when all three films have been picked apart, analyzed, criticized, praised and considered thoroughly, it all depends on how each emotionally tugging story hits its audience.
Among the unique aspects of "City Lights" is that it's a silent movie that was filmed and released when all the other movies hitting theaters at the time had already gone to talking.
This detail has been written and discussed long before I was born.
In the book "Chaplin's Films" author Uno Asplund writes, "[City Lights'] triumph was obvious. Once again Charlie, in a 'silent', had quelled the uproar of the talkies all around him. City Lights offered what was perhaps his most original story-line, constructed round the blind flower girl with pathos and romance, tenderness and feeling. The film is not excessively sentimental, and his audiences smiled through their years. City Lights is one of Chaplin's greatest films - none of his later productions were to reach the same heights." (Asplund 155)
The film withholds its strongest emotional impact until the final scene - right where it needs to and where it's most effective. It's as though the story saves it all for that final sweet moment. I mean, it's not void of emotion until the end. The real touching salvo is saved for that last scene. It's hard, even for the most impassive of audience members, not to get a bit misty in that final scene.
And like "The Kid," Chaplin's musical score fits satisfyingly well. It tells the tale just as much as the pictures do. The score is a mix of the uncaring determined busyness of the city which dissolves into a soft and romantic score that slows city life down to focus on something meaningful and fulfilling. But the city's fast-paced way of life inserts itself from time to time into that romantic interlude. The city finds a way to insert itself into people's otherwise happy lives and merry pursuits.
"City Lights" stands out because Chaplin is stubbornly brilliant, and that brilliance stands out in this movie specifically.
 |
| Virginia Cherrill and Chaplin in "City Lights." |
This detail has been written and discussed long before I was born.
In the book "Chaplin's Films" author Uno Asplund writes, "[City Lights'] triumph was obvious. Once again Charlie, in a 'silent', had quelled the uproar of the talkies all around him. City Lights offered what was perhaps his most original story-line, constructed round the blind flower girl with pathos and romance, tenderness and feeling. The film is not excessively sentimental, and his audiences smiled through their years. City Lights is one of Chaplin's greatest films - none of his later productions were to reach the same heights." (Asplund 155)
The film withholds its strongest emotional impact until the final scene - right where it needs to and where it's most effective. It's as though the story saves it all for that final sweet moment. I mean, it's not void of emotion until the end. The real touching salvo is saved for that last scene. It's hard, even for the most impassive of audience members, not to get a bit misty in that final scene.
And like "The Kid," Chaplin's musical score fits satisfyingly well. It tells the tale just as much as the pictures do. The score is a mix of the uncaring determined busyness of the city which dissolves into a soft and romantic score that slows city life down to focus on something meaningful and fulfilling. But the city's fast-paced way of life inserts itself from time to time into that romantic interlude. The city finds a way to insert itself into people's otherwise happy lives and merry pursuits.
"City Lights" stands out because Chaplin is stubbornly brilliant, and that brilliance stands out in this movie specifically.
As I previously mentioned, he released this silent movie when talkies were booming, trusting that his pantomime artistry could outlast talking pictures.
In his book, "My Autobiography," Chaplin says, "A good silent picture had universal appeal both to the intellectual and the rank and file. Now it was all to be lost. But I was determined to continue making silent films, for I believed there was room for all types of entertainment. Besides, I was a pantomimist, and in that medium I was unique and, without false modesty, a master. So I continued with the production of another silent picture, City Lights." (Chaplin 325)
The film balances slapstick comedy with real emotional weight, as the Tramp’s devotion to the blind flower girl feels completely sincere.
 |
| Harry Myers next to Charlie Chaplin. |
This clown takes care of his little girl who, unfortunately, is a sick and timid child.
The doctor warns the clown not to let his daughter know about his blindness until she's old enough to understand lest the worry wreaks havoc on the poor kid's health. So, the clown does his best to hide his blindness from her all while constantly bumping into things and tripping over everything else. That luckily makes her laugh as she thinks her dad is just being silly.
"But that was too 'icky.' However. the blindness of the clown was transferred to the flower girl in City Lights," Chaplin says. (Chaplin 325)
"City Lights" is a confident movie. Chaplin trusted his expertise, talent, expression, music, and carefully constructed depictions and emotions. That confidence shines in every scene. It's a movie about selflessness, lonliness, and dedication. The final scene is one of the most emotionally moving scenes in any movie before or since.
The doctor warns the clown not to let his daughter know about his blindness until she's old enough to understand lest the worry wreaks havoc on the poor kid's health. So, the clown does his best to hide his blindness from her all while constantly bumping into things and tripping over everything else. That luckily makes her laugh as she thinks her dad is just being silly.
"But that was too 'icky.' However. the blindness of the clown was transferred to the flower girl in City Lights," Chaplin says. (Chaplin 325)
"City Lights" is a confident movie. Chaplin trusted his expertise, talent, expression, music, and carefully constructed depictions and emotions. That confidence shines in every scene. It's a movie about selflessness, lonliness, and dedication. The final scene is one of the most emotionally moving scenes in any movie before or since.
"City Lights" is substantial proof that silent movies, even those from nearly a century ago, can withstand time and film evolution, and still come forth as an impactful experience for modern audiences in 2026.
1) Asplund, Uno. Chaplin’s Films. Translated from the Swedish by Paul Britten Austin, A. S. Barnes, 1976, p. 155.
2) Charlie Chaplin. My Autobiography. Simon and Schuster, 1964.
No comments:
Post a Comment