Consider yourself...remade!
While perusing Netflix, I came across a series called "The Artful Dodger" based on Charles Dickens's, "Oliver Twist."
It caught my eye because ever since last Christmas (2025) when I went on a bit of a deep dive into movie adaptations of "A Christmas Carol," I've been on a sort of Charles Dickens kick.
Since my Scrooge binge, I've started working my way through a reading list of Dickens's books, arranged from easiest to most difficult.
I tried reading some of Dickens's books back in high school. That was over 20 years ago. And I really struggled with Dickens. I never could finish a book of his back then.
I complained about there being too many characters on top of all the convoluted stuff going on in his stories.
I tried reading some of Dickens's books back in high school. That was over 20 years ago. And I really struggled with Dickens. I never could finish a book of his back then.
I complained about there being too many characters on top of all the convoluted stuff going on in his stories.
Plus, I only had a month to read an assigned book in its entirety, which might be easy for some but certainly wasn't easy for a slow reader like me.
"A Christmas Carol" is the only story of his I had ever read in its entirety, and more than once.
So, I decided to give ol' Charlie a second chance.
When I came across "The Artful Dodger" (which I may or may not ever get around to watching), I happened to be reading "Oliver Twist."
Then it occurred to me that there are several movie adaptations of "Oliver Twist." While I've seen plenty of on-line debates and discussions very December about which "Christmas Carol" film is the best, and who makes the better Scrooge. Here it is, November of 2026 and that very discussion is already making the rounds as there's a new adaptation out in theaters right now with Johnny Depp play Ebenezer Scrooge. Meanwhile, I don't recall any such discussions about "Oliver Twist" movies.
"A Christmas Carol" is the only story of his I had ever read in its entirety, and more than once.
So, I decided to give ol' Charlie a second chance.
When I came across "The Artful Dodger" (which I may or may not ever get around to watching), I happened to be reading "Oliver Twist."
Then it occurred to me that there are several movie adaptations of "Oliver Twist." While I've seen plenty of on-line debates and discussions very December about which "Christmas Carol" film is the best, and who makes the better Scrooge. Here it is, November of 2026 and that very discussion is already making the rounds as there's a new adaptation out in theaters right now with Johnny Depp play Ebenezer Scrooge. Meanwhile, I don't recall any such discussions about "Oliver Twist" movies.
That got me curious about just how many film adaptations of Oliver Twist there must be.
I asked Google how many there are, and an estimated 20 major feature-film adaptations dating back to the silent era was hurled back at me as an answer. Tack onto that an estimated 12 made-for-television movies specifically adapting "Oliver Twist," plus one more if you want to include "The Artful Dodger." That looks more like a spin-off, but I'll count it.
So, I searched through a variety of versions and picked out the ones that stood out the most based on their release years and the actors starring in them.
I did the same thing last Christmas by watching a variety of movie versions of "A Christmas Carol."
Like "A Christmas Carol," I started with the book "Oliver Twist" and went from there.
I picked seven adaptations, including a made-for-television film and two Disney movies, to watch and compare. And these are them.
I think "Oliver Twist" is just as significant a story as "A Christmas Carol" in Dickens's literary repertoire. I'm no literary scholar, but I'm not aware of many major novels centered on a poor abused child that force readers to confront just how brutal life could be for the impoverished people of Victorian England.
Dickens uses little Oliver Twist's experiences to offer a scathing critique of English workhouses, the seemingly widespread neglect of children during the era, and the harsh conditions brought about by the English Poor Laws and similar institutions.
Charlie puts Oliver through quite a childhood, dealing with criminals and thieves, danger, neglect, unwantedness, angry adults who have unreasonable disdain for seconds on gruel, and just about everything else London's underworld had to offer during the Victorian era.
The characters in this story, from Oliver himself to Fagin and especially Bill Sikes, are just as firmly cemented in literary culture as Ebenezer Scrooge, Jacob Marley, Tiny Tim, and the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Yet to Come.
The story is brilliant and powerful - very powerful - social commentary delivered through storytelling rather than preaching.
I was curious to see how the writers and filmmakers approached this material in their respective adaptations.
So, here are my thoughts on some film versions of "Oliver Twist." As for "The Artful Dodger," I might get to that another time.
I asked Google how many there are, and an estimated 20 major feature-film adaptations dating back to the silent era was hurled back at me as an answer. Tack onto that an estimated 12 made-for-television movies specifically adapting "Oliver Twist," plus one more if you want to include "The Artful Dodger." That looks more like a spin-off, but I'll count it.
So, I searched through a variety of versions and picked out the ones that stood out the most based on their release years and the actors starring in them.
I did the same thing last Christmas by watching a variety of movie versions of "A Christmas Carol."
Like "A Christmas Carol," I started with the book "Oliver Twist" and went from there.
I picked seven adaptations, including a made-for-television film and two Disney movies, to watch and compare. And these are them.
I think "Oliver Twist" is just as significant a story as "A Christmas Carol" in Dickens's literary repertoire. I'm no literary scholar, but I'm not aware of many major novels centered on a poor abused child that force readers to confront just how brutal life could be for the impoverished people of Victorian England.
Dickens uses little Oliver Twist's experiences to offer a scathing critique of English workhouses, the seemingly widespread neglect of children during the era, and the harsh conditions brought about by the English Poor Laws and similar institutions.
Charlie puts Oliver through quite a childhood, dealing with criminals and thieves, danger, neglect, unwantedness, angry adults who have unreasonable disdain for seconds on gruel, and just about everything else London's underworld had to offer during the Victorian era.
The characters in this story, from Oliver himself to Fagin and especially Bill Sikes, are just as firmly cemented in literary culture as Ebenezer Scrooge, Jacob Marley, Tiny Tim, and the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Yet to Come.
The story is brilliant and powerful - very powerful - social commentary delivered through storytelling rather than preaching.
I was curious to see how the writers and filmmakers approached this material in their respective adaptations.
So, here are my thoughts on some film versions of "Oliver Twist." As for "The Artful Dodger," I might get to that another time.
Oliver Twist (1922) - This silent version of "Oliver Twist" is significant in a number of ways, especially to cinema snobs like me.
Directed by Frank Lloyd, who also directed several other pictures based on literature, including Dickens' "A Tale of Two Cities" (1917), the movie stars child actor Jackie Coogan.
Coogan had already achieved stardom after appearing alongside Charlie Chaplin in the movie "The Kid." I'm sure I've mentioned it before, but Coogan later went on to play "Uncle Fester" in the T.V. series "The Addams Family." But who didn't know that?
Silent screen legend Lon Chaney also stars in this picture as Fagin.
Chaney, "the man of a thousand faces," would later go on to play his most iconic role as the Phantom in 1925's "The Phantom of the Opera." He's also known for playing the titular character in the 1923 film "The Hunchback of Notre Dame."
So, this silent version of "Oliver Twist" is quite a showcase of some of the era's most recognizable cinematic names.
It's unfair to critique just how faithfully or extensively the film adapts the book, considering its hour-long running time and the era in which it was made. Film was expensive, and movies rarely ran much longer than an hour back then. Even so, the movie follows the story rather well and boasts excellent production quality for 1922.
The beauty of silent movies is that they have to work harder to keep audiences engaged through their visual storytelling and animated performances. And this film does so effectively. It knows what to focus on for character development and what deserves only a passing glance to keep the plot moving. Film was precious back then, after all.
Jackie Coogan's performance as Oliver is the most heart-tugging and sympathetic of all the adaptations I've included in this list.
The movie is full of strong emotions, trepidation, and sympathy, along with a healthy dose of disdain for characters like Monks and Bill Sikes. The enjoyment of watching these performances has endured for well over 100 years.
Chaney's portrayal of Fagin is very much a caricature through his mannerisms, facial expressions, appearance (obviously) and larger-than-life performance. Again, being a silent movie, that's what Chaney has to work with.
Directed by Frank Lloyd, who also directed several other pictures based on literature, including Dickens' "A Tale of Two Cities" (1917), the movie stars child actor Jackie Coogan.
Coogan had already achieved stardom after appearing alongside Charlie Chaplin in the movie "The Kid." I'm sure I've mentioned it before, but Coogan later went on to play "Uncle Fester" in the T.V. series "The Addams Family." But who didn't know that?
Silent screen legend Lon Chaney also stars in this picture as Fagin.
Chaney, "the man of a thousand faces," would later go on to play his most iconic role as the Phantom in 1925's "The Phantom of the Opera." He's also known for playing the titular character in the 1923 film "The Hunchback of Notre Dame."
So, this silent version of "Oliver Twist" is quite a showcase of some of the era's most recognizable cinematic names.
It's unfair to critique just how faithfully or extensively the film adapts the book, considering its hour-long running time and the era in which it was made. Film was expensive, and movies rarely ran much longer than an hour back then. Even so, the movie follows the story rather well and boasts excellent production quality for 1922.
The beauty of silent movies is that they have to work harder to keep audiences engaged through their visual storytelling and animated performances. And this film does so effectively. It knows what to focus on for character development and what deserves only a passing glance to keep the plot moving. Film was precious back then, after all.
Jackie Coogan's performance as Oliver is the most heart-tugging and sympathetic of all the adaptations I've included in this list.
The movie is full of strong emotions, trepidation, and sympathy, along with a healthy dose of disdain for characters like Monks and Bill Sikes. The enjoyment of watching these performances has endured for well over 100 years.
Chaney's portrayal of Fagin is very much a caricature through his mannerisms, facial expressions, appearance (obviously) and larger-than-life performance. Again, being a silent movie, that's what Chaney has to work with.
This version of the story makes Fagin less sympathetic than some of the other adaptations do. He's also a lot more distant and less engaging than in other renditions.
Of all the Olivers I've seen, Jackie Coogan is my favorite. Yes, he makes you feel sorry for the poor little blighter, but he doesn't just stand around looking miserable and waiting for someone to take pity on him and come to his rescue. There's a spark of defiance in Coogan's performance. There's a willingness to stand his ground and fight back when circumstances demand it. He's a victim of his circumstances, certainly, but he's no helpless little doormat. Well done, Jackie!
Of all the Olivers I've seen, Jackie Coogan is my favorite. Yes, he makes you feel sorry for the poor little blighter, but he doesn't just stand around looking miserable and waiting for someone to take pity on him and come to his rescue. There's a spark of defiance in Coogan's performance. There's a willingness to stand his ground and fight back when circumstances demand it. He's a victim of his circumstances, certainly, but he's no helpless little doormat. Well done, Jackie!
Oliver Twist (1933) - "Our Gang" (aka "Little Rascals") alum Dickie Moore takes the lead as Oliver in this American talkie adaptation of Dickens's novel, directed by William Wyler.
The film also stars Irving Pichel as Fagin, Sonny Ray as the Artful Dodger, William "Stage" Boyd as Bill Sikes, Doris Lloyd as Nancy Sikes, and Alec B. Francis as Mr. Brownlow.
This Oliver Twist turns up the character's cuteness in certain parts.
The film constantly cuts back and forth between text and scenes, displaying text, cutting to a scene, returning to text, and then back to the scene again. It's a little frustrating.
The movie opens with Oliver's birth, his mother's death, and his adoption by Mr. Bumble. I've noticed that some adaptations don't dwell much on this stage-setting.
Dickie Moore gives a praiseworthy performance, making Oliver a truly sympathetic character. Despite some bad editing and the simplification of Dickens's story, the film manages to capture the essence and spirit of the book.
This Oliver Twist turns up the character's cuteness in certain parts.
The film constantly cuts back and forth between text and scenes, displaying text, cutting to a scene, returning to text, and then back to the scene again. It's a little frustrating.
The movie opens with Oliver's birth, his mother's death, and his adoption by Mr. Bumble. I've noticed that some adaptations don't dwell much on this stage-setting.
Dickie Moore gives a praiseworthy performance, making Oliver a truly sympathetic character. Despite some bad editing and the simplification of Dickens's story, the film manages to capture the essence and spirit of the book.
Some content has been omitted such as the Sowerberry sequence, which includes Oliver's time with the undertaker and his conflict with Noah Claypole. Oliver's resemblance to the painting of his mother, Agnes Fleming, which belonged to Mr. Brownlow, is also briefly touched upon.
Meanwhile, the movie retains the essential elements of the story giving it a feel that it doesn't stray too far from the plot of the book.
It stays respectful enough to the source material with what elements of the book it includes, while making it palpable to a variety of ages.
This movie condenses the story into an hour and 20 minutes. Yet, it doesn't feel rushed or overly compressed. Obviously, omitting some of the story elements make the rest of the content feel well-paced. The story is spread out evenly enough. Since it's the first movie on this list that I watched, I felt it to be a good starting point.
However, it plays a little less dramatically than other versions, especially with the sentimentality sprinkled throughout. Honestly, I don't mind that element. This is a good film to show children who are being introduced to Dickens and the era in which he wrote.
All things considered, it's a good movie that remains faithful enough to the source material.
It stays respectful enough to the source material with what elements of the book it includes, while making it palpable to a variety of ages.
This movie condenses the story into an hour and 20 minutes. Yet, it doesn't feel rushed or overly compressed. Obviously, omitting some of the story elements make the rest of the content feel well-paced. The story is spread out evenly enough. Since it's the first movie on this list that I watched, I felt it to be a good starting point.
However, it plays a little less dramatically than other versions, especially with the sentimentality sprinkled throughout. Honestly, I don't mind that element. This is a good film to show children who are being introduced to Dickens and the era in which he wrote.
All things considered, it's a good movie that remains faithful enough to the source material.
Oliver Twist (1948) - I've read a lot of praise for this adaptation.
This version is a critically acclaimed British film directed by David Lean.
This version is a critically acclaimed British film directed by David Lean.
It's best known for its atmospheric, noir-ish feel along with Alec Guinness's memorable (though some might call controversial) performance as Fagin. The controversy stems from the fact that Fagin is portrayed as a Jewish stereotype complete with an oversized nose.
The British Film Institute later ranked this movie among the top 100 British films.
Lean famously directed other notable pictures such as "Bridge Over the River Kwai," "Doctor Zhivago," and "Lawrence of Arabia." He also directed another Dickens adaptation, "Great Expectations." Consequently, this version seems to be regarded as the definitive Oliver Twist film much like how the 1951 British production, "Scrooge" with Alastair Sim is called the definitive Christmas Carol film.
Unlike the adaptations that come before it, David Lean's version emphasizes the bleak atmosphere, Oliver's timidity, and the corruption that tainted Victorian London. John Howard Davies plays Oliver as a victim of the injustice surrounding him. The weight of his circumstances seems to rest heavily on his shoulders. Audiences can see it in his frail, vulnerable-looking face.
The British Film Institute later ranked this movie among the top 100 British films.
Lean famously directed other notable pictures such as "Bridge Over the River Kwai," "Doctor Zhivago," and "Lawrence of Arabia." He also directed another Dickens adaptation, "Great Expectations." Consequently, this version seems to be regarded as the definitive Oliver Twist film much like how the 1951 British production, "Scrooge" with Alastair Sim is called the definitive Christmas Carol film.
Unlike the adaptations that come before it, David Lean's version emphasizes the bleak atmosphere, Oliver's timidity, and the corruption that tainted Victorian London. John Howard Davies plays Oliver as a victim of the injustice surrounding him. The weight of his circumstances seems to rest heavily on his shoulders. Audiences can see it in his frail, vulnerable-looking face.
His large, weary, and solemn eyes reveal little of his world to those he encounters regardless of where he ends up. But to the audience, they reveal so much about his thoughts and emotions.
His face also conveys a glimmer of hope which is gradually nourished as the story progresses. John Howard Davies is exactly how I imagined Oliver while reading the book. In my opinion, his performance ranks among the three best I've seen in this series.
The movie does seem to skip over or gloss over certain elements of the book, the most notable being the entire burglary scene in which Sikes and Oliver break into the Maylie house. The film shows only their return from the botched burglary. Some members of the Maylie family are also excluded from the adaptation.
The movie does seem to skip over or gloss over certain elements of the book, the most notable being the entire burglary scene in which Sikes and Oliver break into the Maylie house. The film shows only their return from the botched burglary. Some members of the Maylie family are also excluded from the adaptation.
Still, this is the darkest "Oliver Twist" in tone and atmosphere I've watched.
Oliver! (1968) - Now I get to the flick everyone'll quote or sing when "Oliver Twist" is brought up.
It's a highly successful, Oscar-winning musical adaptation of Lionel Bart's 1960 stage musical.
It's a highly successful, Oscar-winning musical adaptation of Lionel Bart's 1960 stage musical.
"Oliver!" is directed by Carol Reed and stars Mark Lester in the title role, Ron Moody as Fagin, and Jack Wild as the Artful Dodger. This version is known for its songs, production value and grand production numbers.
The movie follows the novel rather well though there may be some slight liberties. For instance, the Maylie family and Rose Maylie are eliminated in the movie. That means a considerable portion of Dickens's exploration of kindness, charity, and moral redemption disappears. But the music is catchy, so who really cares?
It's a truly likeable and engaging film full of all the emotions needed for a warm family musical.
The sets impress me just as much as the performances and energy. Each actor puts so much into their roles.
I have to confess this is the first time I've watched "Oliver!" While reading the book, my mind kept thinking back to what few scenes I had seen and the songs I know. So, this was the movie I wanted to watch above the rest.
This is the default cinematic version of "Oliver Twist" most people probably think of first. It's the most famous and enduring version suitable for general audiences.
Fagin is portrayed as more sympathetic than the truly sinister character he is, though the film does bring out this characteristic of his.
With the atmosphere, acting, and performances that make the characters memorable, this movie is a bright theatrical spectacle that impressively manages to retain Dickens's grit beneath all the musical numbers and bright sets.
Like the novel, the musical is not solely concerned with Oliver’s experiences, but with the surrounding characters whose choices, motives, and actions continually shape his fate.
Some of the other movies keep the focus on Oliver, which is understandable for a film platform. If not done right, focusing on other characters can make a movie confusing to say the least.
"Oliver!" is also the most articulate version I've watched for this post.
I appreciate as well as feel disappointed by the movie's abrupt ending. I understand it's likely trying to be a happy ending with plenty of room for the audience to fill in the rest of Oliver's happiness, and the happiness to come with Oliver finally obtaining a loving family he so genuinely deserves.
But its abruptness is very apparent considering how the rest of the movie didn't rush itself.
Regardless, I'm glad I finally watched, "Oliver!" Better late than never.
Oliver Twist (1982) - Before I start in on this adaptation, I did come across an animated musical version of "Oliver Twist" from 1974. That one stars former child actor Josh Albee as the voice of Oliver, along with Les Tremayne as Fagin, and Davy Jones from "The Monkees" as the Artful Dodger. It was produced by Filmation Studios and released by Warner Bros. It didn't grab my attention enough, so I'm skipping over it to get to this version. I just wanted to give it a mention, though.
I know I've mentioned it before on this platform, but the 1984 version of "A Christmas Carol" with George C. Scott is my favorite adaptation of Dickens's story. It sits at the top of my list, shoulder-to-shoulder, with the Alastair Sim film from 1951.
Well, the 1982 version of "Oliver Twist" could be considered its fraternal twin. Both are made-for-television films that aired on CBS, and both were directed by Clive Donner.
"Oliver Twist" stars Richard Charles as Oliver, George C. Scott as Fagin, and Tim Curry as Bill Sikes. An amazing cast indeed!
I haven't seen a performance by either George C. Scott or Tim Curry that I didn't like. And with the recent passing of Curry, I'm glad to include this film in my post.
This adaptation also stars Michael Hordern as Mr. Brownlow. Hordern played Jacob Marley in the 1951 "Scrooge" that I just mentioned. So, we're coming full circle with our Dickens movies!
Richard Charles's portrayal is how I imagined Oliver while reading the book: wide-eyed, naive, observant, curious, and innocent. His bright blue eyes and blond hair give him just the qualities I associate with the character. I felt the most sympathy for the titular character in this film.
And Tim Curry is absolutely perfect as Bill Sikes. Flawless. Intimidating. He plays a thoroughly menacing villain. Curry seems tailor-made for this role, bringing exactly the sort of sinister and unsympathetic presence the character demands.
George C. Scott plays Fagin in a more sympathetic and friendlier light than other adaptations, and even more so than Dickens's original portrayal. He still retains that conniving characteristic for which Fagin is famous. Scott nails the role. I mean, he just gets it right. He may seem friendly to the crew of kids, but he has more self-seeking intentions in mind. By the end, he knows he's not a good person, and knows that everyone sees him for what he is.
This adaptation boasts a high-quality production that pairs well with its screenplay, written by James Goldman. Whereas the musical "Oliver!" gives the story a certain fantasy quality, this film offers a much more plausible, true-to-life depiction of Victorian life and Oliver's experiences.
Donner doesn't pull any punches. The same is true of his "A Christmas Carol" adaptation. The scene in which Bill attacks his mistress, Nancy (Cherie Lunghi), is particularly intense and unmerciful. Thanks to Curry's performance, audiences can really feel just how cruel Bill Sikes is.
It's also worth noting that this film retains the Monks subplot which many other adaptations omit entirely. Monks is crucial to the novel because he is Oliver's half-brother and the architect of the conspiracy against him.
Well, the 1982 version of "Oliver Twist" could be considered its fraternal twin. Both are made-for-television films that aired on CBS, and both were directed by Clive Donner.
"Oliver Twist" stars Richard Charles as Oliver, George C. Scott as Fagin, and Tim Curry as Bill Sikes. An amazing cast indeed!
I haven't seen a performance by either George C. Scott or Tim Curry that I didn't like. And with the recent passing of Curry, I'm glad to include this film in my post.
This adaptation also stars Michael Hordern as Mr. Brownlow. Hordern played Jacob Marley in the 1951 "Scrooge" that I just mentioned. So, we're coming full circle with our Dickens movies!
Richard Charles's portrayal is how I imagined Oliver while reading the book: wide-eyed, naive, observant, curious, and innocent. His bright blue eyes and blond hair give him just the qualities I associate with the character. I felt the most sympathy for the titular character in this film.
And Tim Curry is absolutely perfect as Bill Sikes. Flawless. Intimidating. He plays a thoroughly menacing villain. Curry seems tailor-made for this role, bringing exactly the sort of sinister and unsympathetic presence the character demands.
George C. Scott plays Fagin in a more sympathetic and friendlier light than other adaptations, and even more so than Dickens's original portrayal. He still retains that conniving characteristic for which Fagin is famous. Scott nails the role. I mean, he just gets it right. He may seem friendly to the crew of kids, but he has more self-seeking intentions in mind. By the end, he knows he's not a good person, and knows that everyone sees him for what he is.
This adaptation boasts a high-quality production that pairs well with its screenplay, written by James Goldman. Whereas the musical "Oliver!" gives the story a certain fantasy quality, this film offers a much more plausible, true-to-life depiction of Victorian life and Oliver's experiences.
Donner doesn't pull any punches. The same is true of his "A Christmas Carol" adaptation. The scene in which Bill attacks his mistress, Nancy (Cherie Lunghi), is particularly intense and unmerciful. Thanks to Curry's performance, audiences can really feel just how cruel Bill Sikes is.
It's also worth noting that this film retains the Monks subplot which many other adaptations omit entirely. Monks is crucial to the novel because he is Oliver's half-brother and the architect of the conspiracy against him.
Oliver & Company (1988) - Disney's animated feature film "Oliver & Company" is loosely based on the novel, much like other Disney animated movies are loosely based on their respective source material.
The movie retains the basic plot surrounding an orphan in the city. In this version, Oliver is a cat. And instead of being lost among the streets of Victorian England, Oliver finds himself wandering the streets of modern-day New York City. Fagin’s gang is made up of dogs, with Dodger reimagined as one of them.
Bill Sikes is reimagined as a sort of mob boss and loan shark who rides around in a limousine.
The movie retains the basic plot surrounding an orphan in the city. In this version, Oliver is a cat. And instead of being lost among the streets of Victorian England, Oliver finds himself wandering the streets of modern-day New York City. Fagin’s gang is made up of dogs, with Dodger reimagined as one of them.
Bill Sikes is reimagined as a sort of mob boss and loan shark who rides around in a limousine.
Mr. Brownlow and Rose Maylie are combined into a single character: a little girl named Jenny. Overall, many of the darker plotlines from Dickens's novel are left out. Of course, they are because this is Disney.
The themes of poverty, child exploitation, and institutional cruelty are essentially reshaped into a story about rescue, found family, and emotional comfort. Typical Disney tropes, suitable for one of its child-friendly family flicks. I can only fault Disney for that to a point. The studio is more interested in marketability.
I found this version rather underwhelming, generally speaking. It just doesn't stand out like other Disney animated movies. Sure, the songs are catchy enough, and the celebrity voice acting works well with the New York City setting. Despite the characters being cute animals and little Jenny taking the place of Mr. Brownlow, the story still lacks emotion. It seems to prefer that audiences see the cute animals which would make for great plush toys they can purchase after seeing the movie.
I found this version rather underwhelming, generally speaking. It just doesn't stand out like other Disney animated movies. Sure, the songs are catchy enough, and the celebrity voice acting works well with the New York City setting. Despite the characters being cute animals and little Jenny taking the place of Mr. Brownlow, the story still lacks emotion. It seems to prefer that audiences see the cute animals which would make for great plush toys they can purchase after seeing the movie.
It doesn't feel particularly polished.
Still, I was somewhat invested in the main character, Oliver, especially when he's tricked into leaving Jenny's house by her jealous poodle, Georgette.
There's simply not enough energy here. Even Cheech Marin, voicing Tito, a Chihuahua who is part of Fagin's gang, can't give the film the energy it needs to become a memorable Disney flick or a well-made rendition of "Oliver Twist."
There's simply not enough energy here. Even Cheech Marin, voicing Tito, a Chihuahua who is part of Fagin's gang, can't give the film the energy it needs to become a memorable Disney flick or a well-made rendition of "Oliver Twist."
Oliver Twist (1997) - Disney tried its hand at another adaptation of "Oliver Twist" following its lackluster animated version that I just commented on before this part.
In 1997, the studio went live-action with the story, casting Elijah Wood as Artful Dodger, Richard Dreyfuss as Fagin, and Alex Trench as Oliver Twist.
This is a somewhat caricatured version of Dickens's story, though not in a humorous or satirical way.
While the performances are well done, the characters feel like broad interpretations of Dickens's originals. They're recognizable, but they lack much of their psychological depth.
It is a Disney production, so the movie approaches the story in a more lighthearted classic manner.
It is a Disney production, so the movie approaches the story in a more lighthearted classic manner.
Disney does respect the source material, and although certain elements are presented more lightly, I wouldn't say the story is watered down.
If I were teaching elementary-school children about the novel "Oliver Twist," this is the film version I would show them after they've read the book.
Oliver is supposed to be 12 years old, but he looks like he's seven. Dreyfuss's Fagin is more of a caricature. I get it. Disney wanted to tread lightly around a character who is both Jewish and a villain.
But Elijah Wood makes an ideal Dodger, albeit a family-friendly version of the character. This isn't a bad adaptation.
If I were teaching elementary-school children about the novel "Oliver Twist," this is the film version I would show them after they've read the book.
Oliver is supposed to be 12 years old, but he looks like he's seven. Dreyfuss's Fagin is more of a caricature. I get it. Disney wanted to tread lightly around a character who is both Jewish and a villain.
But Elijah Wood makes an ideal Dodger, albeit a family-friendly version of the character. This isn't a bad adaptation.
It has the expected Disney fairytale flavor, and it's perhaps even a tad whimsical.
It's an enjoyable family-friendly version of the story, done about as well as Disney could be expected to produce. Watching it, one gets the general idea of the story.
It's an enjoyable family-friendly version of the story, done about as well as Disney could be expected to produce. Watching it, one gets the general idea of the story.
დ
The darkest version is, once again, the 1948 film. As for the three best performances as Oliver, first place goes to Jackie Coogan, with Richard Charles coming in a very close second, followed by John Howard Davies.
The best musical score...well, that's easy! "Oliver!" the musical definitely takes that honor.
As I finish this post, I am working my way through "Great Expectations." I don't expect to watch as many movie adaptations of that and comment on them like I did here. The challenge behind writing posts like this is watching the same story again, and again...and again. However, I do want to write one more post...yes, one more...covering even more "A Christmas Carol" adaptations next month.
Read my commentary on adaptations of "A Christmas Carol" from last year -
Tidings of Comfort, Joy, and Too Many Christmas Carol movies: The Multiverse of Scrooges
Tidings of Comfort, Joy, and Too Many Christmas Carol movies: The Multiverse of Scrooges









